2023 Menstrual Product Testimony Resurfaces as Senator Wiener Launches Congressional Bid

California State Senator Scott Wiener's recent announcement of his 2026 congressional campaign has brought renewed attention to a contentious legislative hearing from 2023 concerning gender identity and access to menstrual products. The resurfaced debate highlights the ongoing cultural and political divisions surrounding transgender rights and biological sex in public policy. Wiener, a prominent progressive Democrat, is seeking to represent San Francisco in the U.S. House of Representatives.

The controversy stems from testimony given by Sophia Lorey during a 2023 legislative session. According to Lorey's recent social media post, she testified that "MALES do NOT have a menstrual cycle & do not need tampons in their restrooms." This statement was made in opposition to a bill, likely related to mandating menstrual products in all public restrooms, regardless of gender designation.

Following Lorey's testimony, Senator Wiener reportedly responded by labeling her "homophobic & transphobic for saying men don’t have vaginas," as stated by Lorey in her tweet. This exchange underscores the deep ideological chasm in discussions about gender-inclusive policies. Wiener has been a vocal advocate for LGBTQ+ rights throughout his legislative career, championing various bills aimed at protecting and expanding the rights of transgender individuals in California.

The 2023 incident reflects a broader national conversation regarding the inclusion of transgender individuals in spaces traditionally segregated by biological sex, including restrooms and changing facilities, and the provision of gender-affirming products. As Senator Wiener embarks on his federal campaign, past legislative debates and his responses to them are likely to remain points of scrutiny and discussion among voters and political commentators.