Andrew Torba Warns Trump Administration: Abandon 'Israeli Lobby Baggage' or Face Midterm Losses

Andrew Torba, CEO of the alt-tech social media platform Gab, issued a stark warning to the "Trump admin" on November 5, 2025, threatening electoral repercussions in the upcoming midterm elections if the administration does not shift its foreign policy stance. Torba, a prominent figure in the "America First" movement, specifically called for the abandonment of what he termed "Israeli lobby baggage" and demanded support for "actual America First candidates."

In a post on his social media platform, Torba stated, "Tonight should be a lesson for the Trump admin. Dump the Israeli lobby baggage and start appeasing us or wave the midterms goodbye. We’re not voting for any more wall kissers, token minorities, or grifters. Give us some actual America First candidates or don’t even bother." This statement underscores a growing tension within the conservative and "America First" factions regarding U.S. foreign policy.

Torba, known for founding Gab in 2016 as a "free speech" alternative, has cultivated a platform frequently associated with far-right, alt-right, and Christian nationalist ideologies. His personal and platform's rhetoric often includes strong anti-immigrant and antisemitic sentiments, as highlighted by organizations like the Anti-Defamation League. He advocates for a "parallel Christian society" and has allied with other controversial figures.

The "America First" movement, which gained renewed prominence during the Trump presidency, generally prioritizes U.S. domestic interests and non-interventionism, often expressing skepticism toward international alliances and foreign aid. Historically, the phrase has ties to nativism and antisemitism, a connection that critics frequently point to. The Cato Institute noted that a "Trump era" "America First" policy, while eschewing nation-building, maintained a status quo relationship with Israel and was involved in a "2025 war with Iran," providing a potential context for Torba's critique of the "Israeli lobby."

Torba's ultimatum suggests a perceived disconnect between the Trump administration's actions and the "America First" base's expectations, particularly concerning Middle East policy. The threat of withholding votes in the midterms highlights the internal pressures and ideological battles shaping the future direction of the Republican Party and the broader conservative movement. The call for "actual America First candidates" signals a desire for more ideologically aligned representation in political office.