Charles McElwee's City Journal Piece Honors Robert Redford Following Actor's Death at 89

Charles McElwee, editor of RealClearPennsylvania and former editor at City Journal, recently shared his article for City Journal paying tribute to legendary actor and director Robert Redford. The piece, titled "Robert Redford, the Last All-American Movie Star," was published shortly after Redford's passing on Tuesday, September 16, 2025, at the age of 89. Redford died peacefully in his sleep at his home in Sundance, Utah, a place he deeply cherished.

McElwee's article reflects on Redford's iconic status and enduring legacy in American cinema. The piece highlights Redford's unique journey, noting, "He was an aspiring painter who made a truce with his professional destiny." Despite his striking good looks, Redford was primarily driven by the craft of acting, often shying away from the typical Hollywood limelight.

The tribute delves into Redford's formative years, including his upbringing in Santa Monica and the San Fernando Valley, and his early artistic aspirations in Paris before finding his calling in acting. His career spanned decades, marked by memorable roles in films such as "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid," "The Sting," and "All the President's Men," which solidified his image as a quintessential American leading man. McElwee's article positions Redford as a figure who "broke the generation gap and drew young and old, men and women, to catch a glimpse of him."

Beyond his on-screen presence, Redford was a profound influence on independent cinema, founding the Sundance Institute and the Sundance Film Festival. He was also a passionate environmentalist and advocate for Native American rights. His dedication to these causes and his commitment to fostering new talent underscore a legacy that extends far beyond his acting achievements, cementing his place as a cultural icon.