City Journal Podcast Explores "Masculinity Under Fire" Following Charlie Kirk's Assassination

The Manhattan Institute's City Journal Podcast has released a new episode titled "Masculinity Under Fire: Reclaiming Strength and Responsibility in America," featuring Rafael Mangual, Heather Mac Donald, and Daniel Di Martino. The discussion, recorded on September 24, 2025, delves into the cultural crisis of masculinity, the importance of fatherhood, and the need for positive male role models in the wake of conservative activist Charlie Kirk's recent assassination. The episode was made available to listeners on September 25, 2025.

The panelists opened the discussion by addressing a recent attack on an ICE facility in Dallas, linking it to a broader concern about political violence and rhetoric. Rafael Mangual, the host, stated, "this most recent shooting, of course, comes as the country is still reeling from the loss of conservative activist and Turning Point USA CEO Charlie Kirk." He highlighted Kirk's significant influence on young men, noting the "hundreds of thousands of young men who followed him and looked up to him."

The conversation pivoted to the void left by Kirk's death and the qualities needed in male role models. Heather Mac Donald emphasized virtues such as honor, responsibility, courage, and a willingness to provide. Daniel Di Martino suggested figures like Jesus Christ and biblical apostles, advocating for the positive influence of religion and strong family values. Mangual added that "the soldier, the law enforcement officer, the man who takes risk and puts themselves in harm’s way for something good" and the "loving father and husband" serve as crucial models.

The podcast also examined the societal challenges facing young men, including the perceived demonization of traditional masculine traits and the impact of radicalizing ideologies. Mac Donald criticized the "establishment institutions" for promoting ideas that undermine masculinity, while Mangual underscored Kirk's willingness to take risks in public debate, stating, "he knew on some level... he had assumed this risk, and what I think is most admirable in hindsight is that he took those risks anyway."

The City Journal Podcast, a production of the Manhattan Institute, frequently offers in-depth analysis and commentary on urban policy, culture, and societal issues. This latest episode contributes to its ongoing mission to foster rigorous debate on critical contemporary topics.