Conservative Commentator David French Under Scrutiny Over Alleged Contradictory Public Statements

Prominent conservative writer and commentator David French has become the subject of online criticism following a tweet by "Bonchie" that alleges contradictory stances on religious adherence and political activism. The tweet, posted on October 20, 2025, juxtaposes two purported statements from French: "All these new church goers are scaring me" and, conversely, "The communists and anarchists at the No Kings rally are so peaceful and joyful! What a contrast!"

French has consistently articulated concerns regarding the motivations of individuals newly engaging with church communities, particularly those driven by political rather than spiritual alignment. His commentary often focuses on the phenomenon of "dechurching" and the rise of Christian nationalism, where he critiques the conflation of political identity with religious faith. This perspective questions the sincerity of those joining churches primarily for social or political reasons, suggesting it could dilute the spiritual mission of religious institutions.

While the exact phrasing "All these new church goers are scaring me" has not been directly attributed to French, the sentiment aligns with his public discourse on the potential for political instrumentalization of faith. He has expressed apprehension that when religious institutions become tools for political power, their authentic character may be compromised.

The "No Kings rally," referenced in Bonchie's tweet, refers to a series of anti-Donald Trump protests that occurred around October 18-19, 2025. Participants in these rallies reportedly voiced accusations that Trump was subverting American democracy and infringing on civil liberties.

However, there is no public record or evidence suggesting that David French praised "communists and anarchists" at these rallies as "peaceful and joyful." French is widely known for his advocacy of civility, pluralism, and free speech, often critiquing extremism and political violence from across the ideological spectrum. His writings emphasize the importance of dialogue and mutual respect, even amidst profound disagreements.

French's nuanced position, which champions individual liberty and the rule of law, has at times drawn criticism from more hardline conservatives who advocate for a more confrontational approach in cultural and political debates. The tweet by "Bonchie" appears to frame French's broader calls for civility and understanding as an endorsement of specific groups, creating a perceived contradiction that has sparked online discussion.