Dinesh D'Souza Challenges Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens on Right's Stance on Israel

Conservative commentator Dinesh D'Souza has publicly criticized fellow right-wing media figures Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens, accusing them of contributing to a growing divide within the American conservative movement regarding support for Israel. The "call out" was highlighted by TRIGGERnometry and further elaborated in recent interviews, where D'Souza detailed his concerns over what he perceives as a shift in their positions.

D'Souza's critique centers on Carlson and Owens' recent commentary, which he suggests aligns with anti-Israel sentiments and potentially flirts with "replacement theology." He expressed bewilderment at their stances, particularly given the historical pro-Israel alignment of the American right. "I can understand why Ilhan Omar is the way she is, but I don't really understand why Tucker Carlson is the way he is," D'Souza stated in an interview, noting that Carlson and Omar appear "pretty much on the same side when it comes to Israel."

According to D'Souza, Carlson employs a "shtick" of posing questions with "built-in answers" from "dubious sources" to subtly advance his narrative, while Owens, who previously built her reputation on other conservative issues, has recently adopted an "anti-Semitic element" that D'Souza attributes to her association with Kanye West. He described Owens' current approach as a "bogus investigation" that generates "churn" but lacks reliable facts.

D'Souza emphasized his support for Israel is rooted in theological, cultural, and strategic pillars. He argued against the notion of "replacement theology," asserting that mainstream Christianity incorporates, rather than abrogates, Jewish scriptures and traditions. Culturally, he sees Western civilization as built on the foundations of "Athens and Jerusalem," with Jerusalem representing the moral code. Strategically, D'Souza views Israel as a crucial ally on the front lines against radical Islam, stating, "Israel is really good at it."

The public disagreement underscores an ongoing ideological battle within the conservative landscape, with D'Souza expressing concern that figures like Carlson and Owens are leading young conservatives "down a very bad road." He highlighted the potential for the conservative movement to alienate its traditional pro-Israel base, including evangelical Christians and mainstream Republican donors.