U.S. Representative Randy Fine (R-FL) has ignited a firestorm of controversy after suggesting the use of nuclear weapons in Gaza during a Fox News interview on July 18, 2025. The remarks, made in the wake of the killing of Israeli embassy workers in Washington, D.C., have drawn immediate and strong condemnation from human rights organizations and various political figures. Prominent journalist Yashar Ali reacted critically on social media, stating, "You do not need to hand it to Randy Fine."
During the interview, Congressman Fine asserted that "The Palestinian cause is an evil one, and it is one that we should eradicate. We should be doing to them what we did to the Nazis, and we should be doing it with the same level of resolve." When pressed by the Fox News host if he was suggesting nuclear weapons, Fine responded, "I'm suggesting using whatever it takes to eradicate them."
Human rights groups swiftly denounced Fine's comments as "genocidal" and "reckless," arguing that such statements violate international law and could incite further violence. While some of his Republican colleagues defended his right to free speech, many remained silent or distanced themselves from the specific call for nuclear weapons. The Israeli government has not issued an official statement regarding Fine's remarks.
Fine, who was recently elected as the U.S. Representative for Florida's 6th congressional district in April 2025, is known for his staunch conservative views and a history of controversial actions. Previously, in October 2023, he arranged for messages to be written on artillery shells fired on Gaza. He was also found in contempt of court in October 2024 for making obscene gestures during a virtual hearing.
Yashar Ali, an American journalist and commentator recognized for his investigative reporting and critical commentary on powerful figures, shared his concise disapproval of Fine's statement on Twitter. Ali's direct communication style often sees him publishing information and opinions that challenge established narratives.
The incident has intensified the ongoing debate surrounding political rhetoric concerning the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, highlighting the potential for extreme language to escalate tensions and draw international scrutiny. Fine's comments underscore the deeply polarized nature of discussions on the conflict within U.S. political discourse.