From First Lady Renee to Silvana and Camryn: The Evolving Romantic Journey of Dave Portnoy

Dave Portnoy, the outspoken founder of Barstool Sports, has cultivated a public persona that extends beyond sports commentary and pizza reviews into his personal life. His romantic journey has been a subject of significant media attention, marked by long-term commitments, high-profile relationships, and the unique challenges that come with being a prominent media figure. From his early days building an empire with his wife by his side to more recent public romances, Portnoy's love life has unfolded in the public eye, revealing evolving dynamics and personal growth.

Renee Portnoy (née Satherthwaite)

Dave Portnoy's longest and most significant relationship has been with Renee Satherthwaite, who became Renee Portnoy upon their marriage. The couple began dating in 2005 and tied the knot in 2009. Renee was an integral part of Portnoy's life during the formative years of Barstool Sports, earning her the affectionate nickname "First Lady of Barstool" among fans. She was with him as he built his media empire, with Portnoy stating, "We met when Barstool was nothing, so she rode the grind up with us."

Their marriage lasted for eight years before they announced their separation in 2017. Despite the separation, their relationship has remained notably amicable and complex. In a surprising revelation, Portnoy confirmed in May 2024 that he and Renee are still legally married. A Massachusetts judge reportedly denied their divorce petition because the judge deemed the proposed financial agreement, where Renee did not seek half of his considerable wealth, inequitable given his net worth. Portnoy has openly shared that Renee still has access to his bank accounts, underscoring a deep level of trust and an unconventional, yet strong, bond.

Jordyn Hamilton

Following his separation from Renee, Dave Portnoy entered into a relationship with Jordyn Hamilton in 2017. This romance, however, was short-lived and became a subject of public controversy. The relationship concluded amidst allegations of Hamilton cheating with a SoulCycle instructor, which Portnoy publicly addressed. The accusations led to a backlash against Hamilton on social media, and even SoulCycle faced some illogical criticism from Barstool Sports fans.

Interestingly, Portnoy later recanted his initial claims, suggesting he no longer believed Hamilton had cheated. The brief but tumultuous nature of this relationship highlighted the intense public scrutiny that comes with dating a figure like Portnoy, and how quickly personal matters can escalate into widespread discussions and online drama.

Shannon St. Clair

In 2021, Dave Portnoy was briefly linked romantically to Shannon St. Clair, a former Philadelphia Eagles cheerleader. Their connection appeared to be a short-lived fling, with reports indicating they were spotted together and showed affection at Miami nightclubs. St. Clair also shared images of Portnoy on her social media.

While the age difference between them (Portnoy was 44 and St. Clair 24 at the time) garnered some media attention, the relationship did not develop into a long-term commitment. This period marked a phase where Portnoy's dating life became more visible, often involving younger women and generating buzz in entertainment news circles.

Silvana Mojica

One of Portnoy's most public and significant relationships post-separation from Renee was with model and social media marketing assistant Silvana Mojica. The couple began dating in March 2021 after meeting at the Komodo restaurant in Miami. Their relationship was frequently documented on social media, with Mojica sharing glimpses of their life together, including a memorable Instagram post where she recounted their initial interactions, joking about how busy she claimed to be when Portnoy first asked her out.

Their relationship lasted for approximately two and a half years, ending in November 2023. Portnoy addressed the breakup on his "BFFs" podcast, explaining that he felt there was a "difference in what somebody wants and what the other person wants," and that he "just didn’t think I could give Silvana kind of what she deserves." Mojica also publicly acknowledged the split in a tearful TikTok video, indicating the emotional impact of the separation. This relationship was notable for its public nature and the genuine affection that appeared to exist between them, making their split a significant event for followers of Portnoy's personal life.

Camryn D'Aloia

Most recently, Dave Portnoy has been linked to Camryn D'Aloia. The two were first spotted together publicly in April 2024 at a Boston Celtics game, sparking immediate speculation. Portnoy later casually confirmed he was dating D'Aloia during an appearance on the "Drop A Pin" podcast, while recounting a dramatic boat rescue incident where D'Aloia played a role in getting help. He referred to her as "Cam, um, a girl I'm dating," solidifying their romantic connection.

D'Aloia, who works as a community management associate at Nutrafol, has been seen with Portnoy on multiple occasions since their initial public sighting. While details about their relationship are still emerging, it appears to be Portnoy's current romantic focus. This relationship continues the pattern of Portnoy's dating life being a subject of public interest, with fans and media keen to follow the latest developments in his ever-evolving romantic narrative.

Dave Portnoy's romantic history is as dynamic and public as his career. From his enduring, albeit unconventional, bond with his still-legally-married wife Renee, to the high-profile relationships with figures like Silvana Mojica, his love life has consistently captured headlines. Each relationship, whether brief or long-standing, has offered a glimpse into the personal side of the Barstool Sports founder, showcasing his journey through fame, personal growth, and the complexities of public romance.