Governor Healey Defends Appointment of Trans Woman to Massachusetts Women's Commission Amidst Backlash

BOSTON – Massachusetts Governor Maura Healey has firmly defended her August 2025 appointment of Giselle Byrd, a Black trans woman, to the Massachusetts Commission on the Status of Women (MCSW), following a wave of criticism and online attacks. The controversy escalated in November after an article published by "The Lion" and subsequent social media posts sparked debate and condemnation from various groups. Governor Healey stated, "Giselle Byrd is a highly respected leader in the Boston Arts community who is committed to the advancement of women."

Byrd's appointment, and her subsequent election as Vice Chair of the MCSW’s Programming and Planning Committee, drew significant attention, with some critics referring to her as a "biological male transgender activist." The MCSW, an independent state agency tasked with advancing the rights and equal opportunities for all women and girls, released a statement defending Byrd, noting she had received death threats. The commission emphasized its commitment to protecting all women and girls, regardless of gender identity.

Republican State Representative Alyson Sullivan-Almeida voiced opposition, arguing that the governor should have chosen a "biological woman" for the role. "The people that understand the unique issues and challenges that women face are biological women from birth to death," Sullivan-Almeida remarked. Media personality Megyn Kelly also weighed in, stating on X, "Men make the best women, we all know that," further fueling the online discussion.

Governor Healey highlighted the commission's bipartisan history of LGBTQ+ representation, noting that former Governor Charlie Baker appointed the first transgender woman to the MCSW in 2016. Byrd, who is the executive director of The Theater Offensive, a regional theater company focusing on queer and trans people of color, is the first Black, transgender woman to serve on the commission. She affirmed her resolve to continue in her volunteer role despite the threats.

The Massachusetts Family Institute also criticized the appointment, calling it a "regressive lie" that undermines the understanding of womanhood. Despite the varied reactions, Byrd remains steadfast, asserting, "I will not allow these threats and these harms and actions towards me and my community to silence me." The MCSW continues to stand by its decision, emphasizing that Byrd brings valuable experience and a unique perspective to its mission.