Israeli Minister Benny Gantz Condemns Genocide Scholars' Statement as 'Deceitful Malpractice'

Israeli War Cabinet Minister Benny Gantz has vehemently criticized a recent statement from the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS) concerning Israel, labeling it "nothing short of deceitful, disgraceful malpractice." Gantz, a prominent political figure and former military chief, conveyed his strong disapproval via social media, asserting that the IAGS was engaging in the "cheapening & weaponisation of the term 'genocide' to suit a shameless anti-israel agenda." His remarks underscore the escalating international debate surrounding the conflict and the application of international legal terms.

The International Association of Genocide Scholars issued a statement on October 25, 2023, addressing the situation in Israel and Palestine. While the IAGS statement expressed deep concern over the violence and highlighted risk factors for genocide, it did not explicitly declare Israel's actions as genocide but called for investigations into potential violations of international law. Gantz's tweet, however, referred to a "resolution passed" by the academic body.

Gantz defended Israel's military conduct, citing efforts to minimize civilian casualties and facilitate humanitarian assistance. He pointed to instances where the military "calls off strikes targeting terrorists due to potential civilian collateral damage, sends prior warning of attacks or that even enables the delivery of tons of humanitarian aid and declares ‘humanitarian zones’." He suggested that such actions make Israel "might be most ‘incompetent’ perpetrators of genocide in history."

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) has publicly stated its commitment to upholding international law and minimizing harm to civilians during operations, detailing efforts like issuing warnings and coordinating aid. However, international bodies, including UN reports, have frequently highlighted significant obstacles to aid delivery and the severe humanitarian crisis in Gaza, indicating a complex and contested reality regarding civilian protection and assistance efforts.

The strong condemnation from a high-ranking Israeli official like Gantz reflects the deep sensitivity surrounding accusations of genocide in the context of the ongoing conflict. His statement emphasizes the Israeli government's position that such claims are politically motivated and undermine legitimate defense actions. The debate over the terminology used by academic and international organizations continues to be a focal point in the broader geopolitical discourse.