Mamdani's Plan to End NYC Kindergarten Gifted Programs Draws 'Gaslighting' Accusation

New York City mayoral frontrunner Zohran Mamdani has ignited a fresh wave of debate and criticism with his proposal to phase out Gifted & Talented (G&T) programs for incoming kindergarten students in public schools. This stance aligns with a plan previously put forth by former Mayor Bill de Blasio, drawing immediate and sharp reactions from various corners, including an accusation of "gaslighting" from a social media user. Mamdani's position signals a potential significant shift in the city's approach to early education if he is elected.

Mamdani's campaign stated that he would embrace de Blasio's 2021 plan to gradually eliminate elementary school G&T programs, which have long faced criticism for exacerbating segregation within the school system. Under his proposal, current G&T students would remain in their programs, but no new kindergarten classes would be formed. This move is part of a broader discussion on equity and access in New York City's public schools.

The proposal has been met with strong opposition, with one social media user, Izengabe, stating, "> Zohran Mamdani's tweet is what they call gaslighting. The deBlasio plan you support calls for phasing out all Gifted & Talented programs starting with the incoming kindergarten class." The tweet further highlighted Mamdani's own educational background, noting, "> Mamdani went to the $67,000 a year private Bank Street School for elementary so clearly your rich parents thought early education was important."

The debate over G&T programs has a contentious history in New York City. Former Mayor Bill de Blasio had attempted to phase out the programs in his final months in office, citing concerns about racial inequity and the disproportionate enrollment of white and Asian students. However, current Mayor Eric Adams reversed this decision upon taking office, choosing instead to expand the G&T program and shift its admissions process from a standardized test to teacher recommendations, aiming for greater diversity.

Mamdani's opponents in the mayoral race, including former Governor Andrew Cuomo and Republican candidate Curtis Sliwa, have both voiced intentions to preserve and expand the G&T programs. Critics argue that eliminating these programs removes opportunities for academically advanced students and could lead some families to leave the public school system. Mamdani, who attended both the private Bank Street School and the selective Bronx High School of Science, has also proposed ambitious plans for universal free childcare for children under five.