Psychologist J.D. Haltigan Links 'Suicidal Empathy' to Christian Shift Towards Political Left

Dr. J.D. Haltigan, a prominent developmental psychologist and vocal social commentator, asserted on August 21, 2025, via a tweet, that a phenomenon he terms "toxic empathy" or "suicidal empathy" is actively influencing Christians, particularly women, to align with the political Left. Haltigan's statement, directed at an individual named "Alan," declared, > "Are you really this stupid, Alan? Another name for toxic empathy is suicidal empathy. Yes, it is pulling Christians to the Left because it hijacks & perverts the natural inclinations of most Christians. Women in particular."

Haltigan, known for his extensive research in developmental and evolutionary psychopathology with an h-index of 34 and nearly 5,000 citations, has increasingly become an independent voice outside traditional academic institutions. His public commentary often critiques contemporary societal trends and what he perceives as ideological conformity within academia, a stance underscored by his recent lawsuit against the University of California Santa Cruz regarding their mandatory Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) statements for faculty applicants.

The concept of "suicidal empathy," as articulated by Haltigan, aligns with his broader criticisms of what he describes as the "weaponization of empathy" and the "feminization of academia." He argues that an excessive or misdirected emphasis on empathy, devoid of traditional structures and boundaries, can lead to societal and individual pathologies. This perspective suggests that such empathy, when unchecked, can undermine established norms and contribute to what he refers to as "cluster B psychopathology" traits at a macro-social level.

His tweet specifically targets the perceived impact on Christian demographics, suggesting that their "natural inclinations" are being "hijacked & perverted" by this form of empathy, leading to a shift in political orientation. This commentary is consistent with Haltigan's public discussions on platforms like X and in interviews, where he frequently addresses the intersection of psychology, culture, and politics, often challenging prevailing progressive narratives.

Haltigan’s outspoken views have positioned him as a controversial figure in academic and public discourse, advocating for viewpoint diversity and a return to what he considers foundational principles of scientific inquiry and social order. His recent career trajectory, including a part-time role at a deli following his departure from the University of Toronto, is often cited by him as a consequence of his refusal to conform to what he views as ideological pressures within higher education.