San Francisco City Attorney David Chiu Labeled 'Weakest Politician in History' by Prominent Journalist

San Francisco City Attorney David Chiu has become the target of sharp criticism from prominent local journalist and commentator Susan Dyer Reynolds, who publicly questioned his political efficacy. In a post on social media on September 1, 2025, Reynolds stated, > "What is wrong with you @DavidChiu besides being the weakest politician in San Francisco history?" The highly charged comment, devoid of specific policy references, highlights the often-contentious nature of political discourse in the city.

David Chiu, who assumed the role of San Francisco City Attorney in November 2021, brings a long and extensive background in public service to the position. Prior to his current role, Chiu served as a California State Assemblymember representing eastern San Francisco for seven years, where he authored numerous laws on housing, homelessness, and civil rights. He also notably served as President of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors for six years, a testament to his established presence in city politics. As City Attorney, his office has pursued significant legal actions, including litigation against the opioid industry and challenges to federal policies impacting sanctuary cities.

Susan Dyer Reynolds is known for her outspoken and often critical commentary on San Francisco's political landscape, particularly through her work with the Marina Times and, more recently, the Voice of San Francisco. Her journalistic style frequently involves direct and unsparing critiques of progressive politicians and policies, advocating for more moderate or conservative approaches to city issues like public safety and homelessness. Reynolds has previously been the subject of ethics complaints related to her political affiliations, which she has denied.

The tweet's accusatory tone, labeling Chiu the "weakest politician in San Francisco history," represents a broad and personal indictment rather than a critique of a specific action or policy. This type of direct, unelaborated attack is characteristic of the polarized political climate in San Francisco. It underscores the deep divisions and strong opinions held by various commentators regarding the city's leadership and strategic direction.

Such public exchanges reflect the ongoing debates within San Francisco over its governance and future. Commentators like Reynolds often amplify public frustrations with city issues, while officials like Chiu continue to navigate complex legal and policy challenges. The incident serves as a reminder of the intense scrutiny faced by public figures in the city's dynamic political environment.