A social media commentator, identified by the handle "(((Matthew Lewis))) cults & consequences," recently sparked discussion online by advocating for high-density, inclusive urban development, challenging prevailing sentiments against "Manhattanization" in cities like Los Angeles and San Francisco. The commentator asserted that cities should prioritize human inhabitants and reject discriminatory attitudes, pointing to New York City as an exemplary model of urban living.
In a direct statement, the commentator challenged anti-density views, asking, "> "Don't turn Los Angeles/San Francisco/etc. into Manhattan," ask them: Why not? Cities are for people. And New York is the best one." This perspective aligns with the "Cities for People" movement, which champions urban planning centered on human experience, promoting walkable, transit-rich environments and public spaces for social interaction. Advocates for urban density frequently highlight its benefits, including addressing housing crises, reducing sprawl, and fostering more sustainable and vibrant communities.
The term "Manhattanization" has often been used pejoratively in cities like Los Angeles and and San Francisco, reflecting concerns about overcrowding, increased traffic, and the potential loss of a city's unique character. However, urbanists and housing advocates argue that increased density is crucial for economic vitality, environmental sustainability, and creating diverse urban landscapes. They contend that thoughtful high-rise development can lead to more efficient public services and a wider array of cultural and economic opportunities.
Beyond urban planning, the commentator also emphasized the importance of social inclusivity within city limits. "> Cities are not for hate. Plenty of room for more humans, but no room for that. Take your hate out of our cities. It does not belong here," the post declared. This sentiment resonates with numerous city-led initiatives, such as the National League of Cities' "Cities United Against Hate" program, which empowers local leaders to combat bigotry and foster welcoming environments for all residents.
Cities globally are increasingly implementing programs to promote inclusivity, ranging from public awareness campaigns to support for marginalized groups, recognizing that a city's success is deeply intertwined with its ability to embrace diversity. The call for more "humans" and less "hate" underscores a broader movement towards creating urban spaces where everyone feels they belong, contributing to a richer and more dynamic urban fabric.