Solnit Compares Trump to Reincarnated King George III in Critique of Leadership and Literacy

Writer and activist Rebecca Solnit recently drew a stark comparison between former President Donald Trump and King George III, arguing that leaders disinclined to read or write meaningful books pose a significant challenge to a functioning democracy. This commentary emerged from a Q&A session with John Nichols, published by The Nation on September 8, 2025, and shared by Katrina vandenHeuvel on social media. Solnit's remarks underscore a broader concern about the value of intellectual engagement in political leadership.

Solnit, a prolific author and public intellectual known for her works on feminism, social change, and disaster, expressed her deep concern over Trump's apparent lack of interest in reading. She highlighted instances where Trump's responses to questions about foundational texts, like the Bible or the Declaration of Independence, revealed a superficial understanding. Solnit stated, "He makes George W. Bush and Ronald Reagan look like, I don’t know, Plato and Aristotle."

The comparison to King George III stems from Solnit's view that Trump embodies characteristics described in the Declaration of Independence, which listed grievances against the monarch. She noted that the document's accusations, such as "taxation without representation," resonate with her critique of Trump's actions and approach to governance. Solnit suggested that Trump's public persona is largely a product of television and social media, contributing to a "shallow and glib" public discourse.

Solnit further elaborated on the importance of reading and writing for leaders, citing historical figures like Winston Churchill and Richard Nixon who engaged deeply with written works. She contrasted this with a perceived acceleration in modern society that she believes discourages thoughtfulness and depth. This acceleration, she argued, is partly driven by Silicon Valley's influence on attention spans.

Despite these concerns, Solnit maintains a belief in the enduring power of books and the resilience of reading culture. She pointed to the resurgence of independent bookstores and the vital role of public libraries as "First Amendment outposts" that foster freedom of thought. Solnit emphasized that these institutions support intellectual depth necessary for a healthy democracy, standing in contrast to the "shitty bookcase" she observed in a photograph of Trump.