Stewart Alsop III, host of the "Crazy Wisdom Radio Show," recently sparked discussion on social media by asserting that secularism has transformed the state into a "God-like" entity. He further contended that the advent of the welfare state amplified this power, leading to what he described as "intense suffering" caused by states over the past 150 years.
"why I called out secularism it turned the state into a God and with the arrival of the welfare state it became one (but more like a titan given the intense suffering the states have been responsible for the last 150 years)," Alsop stated in his tweet.
Alsop, known for his podcast "Crazy Wisdom," which delves into cutting-edge topics including technology, artificial intelligence, and philosophy, frequently engages with a diverse range of thinkers and entrepreneurs. His platform often explores unconventional connections between various subjects, aiming to expand understanding of reality.
The critique of secularism, as articulated by Alsop, aligns with broader philosophical arguments suggesting that while secularism aims for neutrality by separating religion from the state, it can inadvertently establish the state as a new form of authority. This perspective posits that the state, in its quest for a neutral public sphere, can assume a quasi-religious role, potentially marginalizing alternative worldviews.
Furthermore, Alsop's assertion regarding the welfare state's role in exacerbating state power and contributing to suffering echoes historical criticisms. Analysts have pointed to the state's immense power as a source of harm, particularly over the last century and a half, through mechanisms such as wars, authoritarian regimes, and economic policies leading to inequality. Even well-intentioned state interventions, when implemented without sufficient checks, can result in significant unintended consequences and societal challenges.
Alsop's comments highlight an ongoing debate about the scope and limitations of state power in modern societies. His perspective underscores a critical view that questions the benevolent nature of an ever-expanding state, particularly when divorced from traditional moral or religious frameworks, and its historical impact on human well-being.