San Francisco Supervisor Joel Engardio Recalled by 65% of District 4 Voters

San Francisco Supervisor Joel Engardio was decisively recalled from office on Tuesday, September 16, 2025, with preliminary results showing approximately 65% of District 4 voters favoring his removal. The recall effort stemmed primarily from Engardio's support for Proposition K, a 2024 ballot measure that permanently closed a two-mile stretch of the Great Highway to vehicles, transforming it into the Sunset Dunes park. The outcome marks the first time in San Francisco's history that a supervisor has been recalled.

Political observer Armand Domalewski expressed profound sadness following the results, stating in a social media post, "While @JoelEngardio’s loss tonight was not a shock to anyone, it still remains a heartbreak. I’ve been involved in SF politics for over a decade now, and I have never met a man kinder, more decent, and more sincere than Joel. It is very sad to see the good guys lose." This sentiment highlights the personal impact of the political decision on some observers.

Engardio conceded the race shortly after the initial results were released, telling supporters, "My time as a supervisor is going to be shorter than expected. I accept the election results. But we can still celebrate because we're on the right side of history. Sunset Dunes is a success. It's good for the environment, it's good for our local economy, it's bringing joy to people of all ages." He maintained that he had no regrets about supporting Prop. K, despite the strong opposition within his district.

The recall campaign gained momentum after Prop. K passed citywide, even though 64% of District 4 voters opposed it. Residents argued that the highway closure worsened traffic in their neighborhoods and felt betrayed by Engardio's stance. San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie will now appoint an interim successor to fill the remainder of Engardio's term, with the District 4 supervisor seat expected to be on the ballot again in June 2026.